https://x.com/bskimike22802/status/2053526652068548667?s=51&t=cLq01Oy84YkmYPZ-URIMYw
" Oh, I love this argument. I genuinely do. Let me introduce you to a concept they teach in about third grade: the difference between a NOUN and an ADJECTIVE. "Democratic" — ADJECTIVE. It describes a PROCESS. A car with a fast engine is not a "fast." A library that is quiet is not a "quiet." And a republic that uses voting to select representatives is not a "democracy." The process does not rename the institution. This is not complicated. "Democracy" — NOUN. A specific form of government where the PEOPLE vote DIRECTLY on the laws themselves. Majority rules. No filter. No constitutional ceiling on what that majority can do to the minority. That is what the word means — and that is EXACTLY what the Founders said they were NOT building. (Federalist No. 10. Go read it. I'll wait.) Now, since you want to hang your entire argument on "but we vote" — here is my challenge to you: NAME ONE THING — just ONE — that you, as an individual American citizen, vote for DIRECTLY at the federal level. Not at the state level, at the federal level. Just one. One more question, if we are a democracy, can 51% of the people decide to get rid of the Constitution, get rid of the House, or get rid of the Senate... All of it? Just wondering because that is how Democracies work. I will be here. Scientifically. Patiently. Waiting."
I'm not going to copy/paste the whole exchange, it's available through the link above. However, this is an excallent response to those who insist that the US is a democracy.
No comments:
Post a Comment