https://zacharythacher.substack.com/p/why-liberals-cant-moderate?r=28q7xt&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=post%20viewer
"If Democrats would moderate, his pitch goes, then they can take the left and the center, and used the next two years to assemble a mighty coalition that will win both houses and the executive in 2028, which gives them a shot of balancing the Supreme Court since Thomas and Alito will crack 80 in the new Democratic administration, which may pass age limits that guess what, will start at age 80.
The problem with this lovely solution to the Democratic problem is that it ignores who Democrats have become as a party in the new millennium. Rahm Emanuel is 66 years old, he graduated Sarah Lawrence College in 1981. Can you imagine a Hebrew-speaking Jewish Zionist who goes to a Modern Orthodox shul applying to Sarah Lawrence in 2026?
The Democratic Party — the brand, the identity, the moral underpinnings of their movement — is not about pragmatism, universalism or even patriotism. It’s about social justice, multiculturalism and socialism in a zero-sum game of we win, you lose. I know this because, as a Hebrew-speaking Jewish Zionist who goes to a Modern Orthodox shul, I lost and Zohran Mamdani won. I’m an “AIPAC monster” and a “racist” for all of those descriptors I just listed.
The reason why Rahm Emanuel’s calculus is a fantasy is that he won’t grapple with the fact that parties evolve. Republicans have changed a lot in the past 12 year. Isn’t it fair to say that Democrats have too, and for even longer?
The Democratic Party — and its support system in the academy, media and culture — now believe that perfecting America requires skin color, gender and sexuality diversity at all strata of society. It’s unclear how they’ll know when they’ve achieved it, maybe by looking demographics, maybe by vibes. But higher rates of favored skin color and gender representation are a must, not a want. It is the only policy all Democrats agree with.
Since that won’t happen organically, they will use brute force to manifest their ideals. The terms have changed over the years, from Affirmative Action to DEI to whatever euphemism is coming next, but the method is always the same: promote the groups who are perceived as victims, and suppress the groups they perceive as oppressors.
If a wealthy gay woman who recently immigrated from Ghana is competing for a job or academic position against a poor straight man from Appalachia, she will win benefits, he will face impediments. Based on their skin color, gender and sexuality.
Now if a Jew, which represents 2.2% of the American population and 0.2% of the world, competes with a Muslim, 25.6% of the world/1.6% of America, the Jew loses, because they are perceived as having lighter-color skin, even though their American populations are similar.
This isn’t a scientific or a democratic practice, it’s a totalitarian worldview that relies on abstract claims of social justice. And if you’re not for social justice, you’re a racist, because only a racist wouldn’t tolerate discrimination. Yes, this is a 180° reversal of the logic of the Civil Rights Movement, which sought to end discrimination, but like I said, things change over time.
Meanwhile, the social justice thinking of the Democratic Party extends to economic justice, so redistributive tax policies are a necessity. They don’t actually work, blue states have higher rates of income inequality than red states and higher costs of living, but the yardstick for Democratic policies aren’t science or other quantitative measures, they’re about a feeling of being righteous. Some people win, like unionized labor (10% of wage earners), and others lose, like public school students in underperforming urban schools. The fact that the vast majority of these students have darker skin than lighter skin private school kids isn’t a factor.
Where Rahm Emanuel gets it wrong is that Democrats are not a technocratic party, like what Mike Bloomberg seems to believe. It’s a party that, for many, has replaced the synagogue or church with political identity. Being liberal is more of a religious-type of politics. This makes it immune to moderation, because you never want to be half right, or half just, or half correct. You’re either right, or you’re wrong.
My prediction, which I’m sure will be wrong in many ways, is that Democrats will win big in the midterms this November and then, depending on how Republicans handle the Trump succession, they will face an steep uphill battle in 2028 and most likely lose the presidency while holding onto one house, if at all."
No comments:
Post a Comment