To start with, I'm not particularly obsessed with Talarico, but I do want to make a point or two.
1. He is clearly trying to put a Biblical veneer on DFL policies and things leftists support. My question is how many leftists who already are anti Christian will flock to support this guy because he makes a twisted case that the Bible supports abortion. FWIW, he's pretty much arguing that getting an abortion is one's christian duty.
2. If he was a GOP candidate making these sorts of explicitly Biblical arguments for conservative policies, the ASPL would be going insane. Look at how they reacted to Kirk making an argument against abortion which didn't rely on Scripture and how they objected to it because his objection was rooted in his faith.
I completely understand that he'll get votes simply because there's a D after his name on the ballot, but it's absurd to argue that he's making a case for something much closer to a theocracy than anyone running for office on the right.
https://x.com/collinrugg/status/2029234363314098679?s=51&t=cLq01Oy84YkmYPZ-URIMYw
"Democrat and Presbyterian seminarian James Talarico has won the Democratic primary for U.S. Senate.
Here are some of his beliefs:
- Thinks illegal immigrant children are more patriotic than American children.
- Thinks the Torah tells you how to give an abortion.
- Thinks the trans community needs abortion too.
- Think there are 6 genders.
- Thinks God is “nonbinary.”
- Thinks the Bible supports gay marriage.
- Thinks Jesus supported abortion because he talked to and was kind to women.
- Thinks the story of Mary's Annunciation is proof that God supports abortion."
https://x.com/d_b_harrison/status/2029584378977034282?s=51&t=cLq01Oy84YkmYPZ-URIMYw
Name all 6.
https://x.com/afpost/status/2029353944908976305?s=51&t=cLq01Oy84YkmYPZ-URIMYw
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DVeJ3bcDpwE/?igsh=Zjk2MXlmM2tmcWU3
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DVoh3F3D6au/?igsh=c29pMzJ4YjZybnkz
https://x.com/repmattschaefer/status/2030343533740093485?s=51&t=cLq01Oy84YkmYPZ-URIMYw
For a Christian to deny that a human baby is not "God's creation" seems off brand.
https://x.com/jacktronprime/status/2030496180409401386?s=51&t=cLq01Oy84YkmYPZ-URIMYw
" Talarico is a HERETIC who abuses the word of the living God to further a political agenda. He treats Jesus like a cheap mascot to defend the indefensible in a Christian framework. This is not something that should be taken lightly.
President Trump doubts he’ll get into heaven. Many of his sins are public. I don’t personally know any Christians who would say Trump has lived a life that a Christian should emulate (though I pray for his salvation regularly). He’s a politician whose policies more closely align with a Christian worldview, so Christians voted for him over Kamala (pro-abortion, pro-transing kids, pro-open borders etc).
What Trump does not do is distort scripture to condone infidelity or other sins beneficial to his political ambitions. If he did, we would scream just as loudly.
That’s the difference. Hope this helps."
Jason Howerton
Howerton makes a good point. Trump isn't claiming to be a Christian, he doubts he'll go to Heaven, his sins are loud and public and he's certainly not being held up as an example of a Christian life. Yet he does support policies that are more in line with many Christians positions than any of those he's run against. Trump is simply who he is, for better or worse, he's not cosplaying to get votes.
https://x.com/davidbahnsen/status/2030937903413489825?s=51&t=cLq01Oy84YkmYPZ-URIMYw
https://x.com/bartbarber/status/2031106721750323503?s=51&t=cLq01Oy84YkmYPZ-URIMYw
A long thread, but interesting.
https://x.com/watchchad/status/2030820298870734880?s=51&t=cLq01Oy84YkmYPZ-URIMYw
"People say I’m the villain for calling out the James Talarico heretical claims. Then I’ll be the villain. I’m happy to spend the next few months knee deep in your cries of “fact check.” Let’s get started.
FACT CHECK: The Claim that “God is Nonbinary”
Texas State Representative James Talarico said the following during debate on transgender legislation in the Texas House in 2021:
“God is nonbinary.”
He LATER clarified that he meant God transcends human gender categories.
Christians should approach statements like this carefully, not politically, but biblically.
Scripture actually gives us very clear language about how God reveals Himself. Jesus consistently refers to God as Father.
Matthew 6:9
“Pray then like this: Our Father in heaven, hallowed be your name.”
John 20:17
“I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God.”
The Son reveals the Father. This is not cultural language. It is revelation language
Throughout Scripture, God chooses personal, relational language that reflects fatherhood, authority, provision, and covenant.
Isaiah 64:8
“Yet you, Lord, are our Father. We are the clay, you are the potter.”
This does not mean God is biologically male. Christianity has never taught that. God is spirit (John 4:24).
But it does mean God Himself chose how He would be revealed anthropomorphically. God is not a physical being like humans. He is eternal, immaterial, and uncreated. So in that sense, God is not “male” the way humans are male.
However, the critical issue is how God chose to reveal Himself personally. The language He consistently used was Father.
Talarico was using progressive liberal ideology to make a theological point on a modern topic. When modern ideology replaces that revealed language with categories like “nonbinary,” it is not clarifying Scripture, but reframing God according to modern cultural categories.
Christians should be cautious anytime theology starts moving in that direction with its language.
The question is simple:
Do we allow culture to redefine God, or do we allow God to define Himself through Scripture? Talarico knew the point he was making.
Historic Christianity has always answered the question the same way. So when Scripture uses the language of Father, it is not merely symbolic. It describes eternal relationships within the Godhead.
This is why Jesus constantly refers to:
“My Father”
“Your Father”
“The Father who sent me”
The Gospel of John alone records Jesus referring to the Father over 100 times.
This is not accidental language.
It is theological revelation.
Now, Scripture also affirms that God possesses qualities humans often associate with both paternal and maternal care.
For example:
Isaiah 66:13
“As a mother comforts her child, so will I comfort you.”
But notice the difference.
Scripture sometimes compares God’s care to a mother’s compassion, but God still identifies Himself as Father.
These are descriptions of God’s attributes, not redefinitions of God’s identity.
The danger arises when modern cultural frameworks attempt to replace revealed language with contemporary ideological categories.
The term “nonbinary” is a modern concept rooted in contemporary gender theory. It does not come from Scripture or classical Christian theology.
God has already revealed who He is."
https://x.com/williamwolfe/status/2031062141319405930?s=51&t=cLq01Oy84YkmYPZ-URIMYw
"I've been expecting this. James Talarico is "Judgement Day" for the anti-Christian Nationalist cottage industry.
Every Leftist academic, pundit, pastor, etc., who has been decrying the dangers of "Christian nationalism" is about to get outed as a total HYPORCRITE and FRAUD as they line up to cheer for a man who is running a more "Christian nationalist" campaign than anyone in the country - just on progressive/Woke so-called "Christian" values (that aren't anywhere to be found in the Bible).
So what's the answer from mainstream media? It's time to "retire" the term.
The schadenfreude is so rich."
